Socialnomics – Social Media Blog

Google Super Bowl Ad

February 9, 2010 · 6 Comments

By Erik Qualman

While there were mixed emotions about Google’s Parisian Super Bowl ad as a whole it seems to have been received very positively. Some of the critical feedback centered around the fact that it didn’t have the funny punch line or that “AHA” moment, rather it was simply a nice commercial. One thing Google did get right though is that the commercial works without sound. This is very important for the Super Bowl. Many people watch the Super Bowl at large parties, bars, etc. that either don’t have sound or it’s tough to hear over the cacophony of noise. So, even though Google is new to the Super Bowl commercial business, other major brands should learn a lesson from Google, specifically does the commercial work without sound? If it doesn’t your company may have just flushed $2.6 million down the drain.

Bookmark and Share

→ 6 CommentsCategories: Google
Tagged: ,

New Facebook Look … Again

February 5, 2010 · 7 Comments

By Erik Qualman

Facebook revealed a new look today. If you haven’t seen this change yet, you will.  Inside Facebook indicates 80 million users got the new home page layout February 4, and more will be seeing the redesign shortly.

The new Facebook layout includes a new home page design, and an applications and games dashboard.  Below is a sneak peak.

Facebook's New Look

Facebook's New Look Came Out Today

My 3-minute reaction is that I like it.  If over the course of the next 24-hours that opinion changes I will let you know!  The main change is to the top and side navigation; specifically, it is easier to find the items you use most: messages, new requests, notifications, etc.

Benefits of the new Facebook

Another feature is they showcase who’s online now (left nav) in an attempt to increase the use of their chat feature. They’ve also made the reminders, like for birthdays, a little more prominent.   I’ve only reviewed for a few minutes, but so far there is nothing glaring that I can’t find.

Bookmark and Share

→ 7 CommentsCategories: Facebook
Tagged: , , ,

4 Social Media Questions Answered

February 3, 2010 · 6 Comments

By Erik Qualman

I periodically find it helpful to put together a list of the top questions I’m asked by people, corporations and the media.  Hopefully you find my answers helpful.

1]  Do most companies seem to have clear strategies and direction with social media or does it seem like people are still trying to figure out what to do with it and how it can help them?

Some of the good companies have a clear strategy, while others are just dipping their toe in the water.  The key with social media is to fail fast, fail forward and fail better.  You aren’t going to get it right the first time, but you aren’t going to learn anything if you don’t take that first step.  The beauty of social media is that your customers are very forgiving and at the same time, helpful at expressing exactly what they need from you as a company.  It is the world’s largest focus group on Steroids.

2]  Do you think most companies will go “in-house” with their social media, or will there still be a place to hire the freelance person who gets paid to Tweet, or the consulting firm?

Since social media touches ever facet of the business it inherently lends itself to most activity being taken in-house.  Also, the conversations need to be genuine and it’s easier to establish that trust if it is coming from you, not a surrogate. Social media is not an ‘or,’ it’s an ‘and’ in marketing. Dell recently indicated that they originally had 40 people focused on social media. They soon realized it’s not just the 40 people that need to own social media, it’s the entire company. Every person, whether it’s someone on the phone answering customer service, or any other employee, these employees have a Facebook accounts, they have Twitter accounts, and they are representing Dell whether it is working hours or not.

While a majority will reside “in-house,” for certain components it still makes a world of sense to bring in help from a HubSpot, Mari Smith, Chris Brogan, Tamar Weinberg, Kami Huyse, David Meerman Scott, Charlene Li, Sarah Evans, Lee Odden, Brian Breslin, etc.

3]  What, in your view, are the most common ways that corporations have embraced social media? Is it making a Facebook page, sending official Tweets, or maybe a mix of things?

The good companies know a sound social media strategy is much more than a Facebook Fan Page or setting up a Twitter Account.  However, there are some companies that think putting up only a Facebook Fan Page is a sound social media strategy.  The good companies know that social media has to be integrated into everything that they do – it is a part of their overall strategy since it touches every facet of the business.

I was fortunate to share the stage with Alan Mulally (CEO of Ford) and they have used social media as a driver to help not only change the external perception of the Brand, but it has helped change the internal culture – he mentioned this in his speech.  He was also a recent keynote at CES (Consumer Electronics Show) – this spot is normally reserved for Bill Gates, Steve Jobs, etc.  not the CEO of a car company – that is a radical change in a short period of time.  They have shifted their spend from 10% digital to 25% digital.  Historically their competition spends less than 10% of their marketing dollars are digital initiatives.  It is no coincidence that they haven’t had to take out a government loan and that their Stock Has increased from $1.5 to $11.  In fact the Altimeter Group did a study that showed Companies actively engaged in Social Media had higher revenue increases than those that weren’t active.  Also it has flowed downstream to production to where their cars are enabled with WiFi, MP3 Synch Technology, ability to tweet & status update via voice commands while driving, etc.  This is a reflection of the great work that James Farley, Scott Monty and others are doing there.

4]  Where do you see the future of social media?

Much will be around data aggregation and the sharing of this information amongst the social graph.  What have my friends purchased?  What services or restaurants have they rated highly?  You will see search and social media begin to merge with the end result being we will no longer search for products and services via a search engine, rather they will find us via social media.  This is one of the true powers of social media!  I care more what my friends and peers link than about what an algorithm or opaque rating system spits out.

Also, users will demand more control of their privacy.  In a simplified example some photos a user doesn’t mind sending to the universe, while others they only want to send to 5 select people.

Oh, and thirty other things we haven’t even dreamed up…that’s what is exciting!

Bookmark and Share

→ 6 CommentsCategories: Social Media
Tagged: , ,

Fun Video: Into the Twittersphere

January 30, 2010 · 3 Comments

By Erik Qualman

This video is an oldie, but a goodie.  With over two million views on YouTube it has struck a cord with many.

Aside from being funny, what I like about it is that it points out many false truths about Twitter.  For example when it showcases people tweeting “Watching TV with my cat” or “I forgot how much I like pickles” this is what people that don’t use Twitter believe Twitter is all about.

Sure some mundane chatter occurs in Twitter, but a majority of activity on Twitter is business, information sharing and cause (helping Haiti is particularly hot right now) related.

So, enjoy watching this funny video, but understand that it is missing the real power of Twitter.    Hat tip to the folks at Current Super News for putting this together.

Bookmark and Share

→ 3 CommentsCategories: Twitter
Tagged: , , , ,

Despite Social Media Claims, Census is a Potential $340 Million Money Pit

January 15, 2010 · 2 Comments

By Erik Qualman

Many applaud the U.S. Government for using Facebook, MySpace, Twitter, YouTube and a Blog (Robert M. Grovers Director of the United States Census Bureau) for this year’s Census.  None of these tools existed the last time the census occurred in 2000, so kudos for the progression and a hat tip to social media.  However that is where the applause possibly ends.  In 2000 the Commerce Department spent an estimated $147 million dollars to promote the census.  census social mediaTen years later, the budget has grown to $340 million dollars.  This dramatic increase of the budget is a marketers dream as they already have plans to spend it frivolously on Super Bowl Ads, NASCAR, Winter Olympics and tailgate parties.  Marketers’ collective jealousy across the land is palpable for such a campaign that seems to have little accountability as indicated in an article by Mike Riggs of thedailycaller.com:

“In its review of the 2000 Census’s marketing efforts (which also included a road tour) the Government Accountability Office (GAO) observed that the bureau had spent 260 percent more to market the 2000 census than its predecessor — $3.19 per household in 2000 versus $0.88 in 1990 — but fared worse in every category: The response rate was 65 percent in 1990 and 64 percent in 2000, and the return rate, which the GAO considers “a more precise indicator of public cooperation with the census than the mail response rate,” declined from 74 percent in 1990 to 72 percent in 2000.”

Also palpable is the ire and bewilderment of  taxpayers, who are skeptical of a $340 million dollar spend in this difficult financial climate.

Ironically, it was less than two years ago that Obama was able to fund raise record amounts of money with little upfront investment.  His team was able to do this through creative use of technology and social media and it empowered young and old alike to make a historical difference.

Hopefully some of this progressive thinking can be used to correct what appears to be a $340 million dollar boondoggle.  While offline marketing activity is needed it needs to be used in a coordinated fashion with newer mediums like search, social media, mobile, etc.   Also, I’m not sure that we needed to more that double the marketing budget.  For example, why not use tools like Facebook and Twitter so that users can easily fill out the 10 minute questionnaire?  People are more than willing to help out as the indicated by the Causes application of Facebook that has over 24 million active monthly users that help donate dollars to various causes.  Most recently over $100,000 has been raised for the Haiti relief efforts.

Hence, if we (it’s our tax dollars remember) run an ad during the Winter Olympics why not prompt users to fill out the census via Facebook, Twitter, Text Messaging?  There are over 100 million users on Facebook in the United States.   To be fair, Mr. Grovers may already have plans to do this in the $340 million dollar marketing plan.  However, the beauty is that if it isn’t currently in the plan it can easily be adjusted to accommodate such; that is one of the true beauties of online, social media and mobile.

As of now, unless I’m at an appropriate football tailgate or receive a knock on the door, I ‘m not sure where I can easily fill out the census.  Another quick thought, why don’t they try to capture as many names electronically saving on the cost of paper/shipping/environment and then suppress the names (i.e. don’t mail paper to those that have already completed the form) they capture before starting the mailing a few weeks/months later?

If we are going to double the budget we might as well be progressive than simply buying more traditional media and putting up a Facebook Fan Page .  For example, why not have a page that shows a current tally/ongoing results of the census itself?  We live in a world of transparency, what would be more transparent than that?  Instead if I go to the Census Bureau site, in regards to filling a form out online  it tells me:  No, not this time. We are experimenting with Internet response options for the future. The tag-line of the site is “It’s in Your Hands.” Maybe this is appropriate since it doesn’t appear to be at my fingertips.

Bookmark and Share

→ 2 CommentsCategories: Social Media
Tagged: , ,

Top 20 Social Media Experts

January 13, 2010 · 21 Comments

By Erik Qualman

I had some fun this week in my ClickZ column by highlighting the best in brightest in the social media field.  You can find the detailed article here: Social Media All-Stars

As the title showcases I selected 10 Social Media All-Stars for each team.  You can see these All-Stars in the images on this post, or the list is below.  Pete Cashmore is such a social media rockstar that he would throw out the first pitch:

American League All-Star Team:Mari Smith Social Media All-Star

  • Gary Vaynerchuk: @garyvee
  • Brian Solis: @briansolis
  • Mari Smith:  @MariSmith
  • Shiv Singh: @shivsingh
  • Clay Shirky: @cshirky
  • Peter Shankman: @skydiver
  • David Meerman Scott: @dmscott
  • Jeremiah Owyang: @jowyang
  • Lee Odden: @LeeOdden
  • Dave Morin: @davemorin

Guy Kawasaki National League All-Star Team

  • Scott Monty: @scottmonty
  • Valeria Maltoni: @ConversationAge
  • Charlene Li: @charleneli
  • Guy Kawasaki: @GuyKawasaki
  • Mitch Joel:  @MitchJoel
  • Brian Halligan: @bhalligan
  • Seth Godin
  • Paul Gillin: @pgillin
  • Chris Brogan: @chrisbrogan
  • Josh Bernoff: @jbernoff

Honorable MentionSocial Media Experts
Corey Perlman, Dan Zarella, Louis Gray, Richard Binhammer, Frank Eliason, Richard Binhammer, Robert Scoble, Lee Aase, Eric Bradlow, Sally Falkow, Don Steele, Julien Smith, Michael Lazerow, Sarah Hofstetter, Mack Collier, Mike Barbeau, Todd Defren, Tom Gerace, Elizabeth Pigg, Richard MacManus, Jon Gibs, Chris Cunningham, Paul Beck, Matt Goddard, Chris Heuer, CC Chapman, Chris Penn, Shel Israel, Tamar Weinberg, Larry Weber, Morgan Johnston, Tim Washer, David Armano, Nick O’Neil, Mike Stelzner, Jason Falls, Dave Kerpen,  Sonia Simone,  Adam Singer, Michael Brito, Geoff Livingston, Wayne Sutton.

Bookmark and Share

→ 21 CommentsCategories: Social Media · Uncategorized
Tagged: , ,

Social Media vs. SEO

January 11, 2010 · 7 Comments

By Erik Qualman

Niall over at SimplyZesty asked Alastair McDermott of WebDoctor and I to write-up some thoughts on SEO versus Social Media in 2010.   Here’s the take I supplied:

SEO vs. Social MediaThere will be a blending of search and social. We are already seeing this with Twitter being incorporated into the Google organic results. Consumers we will be privy to a) sponsored listings b) organic listings c) social graph listings. During a purchase decision we will utilize all three of these data points – however I would strongly argue that item c – what our friends and peers think – will be “weighted” the most. We are seeing “word of mouth” transforming into “world of mouth.”

If I have my first baby and need to purchase a child seat for the car and I can see via social/search tools that 30 of my friends have purchased a child seat in the past 18 months. And, of those 30, 23 have purchased the exact same model and all have had a great experience, well then I’m going to be fairly confident in that purchase decision and I may not even look at the sponsored or organic listings.

SEO is still a vital part of any product/companies health (especially in the here and now), but as we look down the road, the simple fact is that I trust more what my friends and peers think than an algorithm. So good companies are starting to listen to what is being said in the “social sphere” and adjusting their products/services accordingly.

The full article at SimpleZesty is here:  “The Looming Battle Between SEO and Search”

A big thanks to Niall for reaching out to me as this stuff is fun!

Bookmark and Share

→ 7 CommentsCategories: Search Engine · Social Media
Tagged: ,

Tweet While Driving Hands Free

January 8, 2010 · 3 Comments

By Erik Qualman

“Have You Driven a Ford Lately?”  Ford may want to rekindle this old slogan.  With Alan Mulally spearheading the way, Ford is quickly changing its image as a “truck only” company in the United States.  It’s hard not to like Mulally’s passion and enthusiasm.  I was fortunate to be a keynote speaker along with him at a private event in  October.  This was a non-tech event so I was floored by how much he discussed social media and technology.  Fast forward to today and he was on  stage this week as a Keynote speaker at the Consumer Electronics Show (CES) in Las Vegas.  This in itself is a tremendous step in the right direction for an automaker – these CES speaking slots are generally reserved for the Steve Jobs of the world.  While at Boeing, Mulally helped design the digital cockpit and now he is doing the same with Ford.  Some of the more exciting features:

  • Ability to stream Pandora Radio
  • MyFord Touch is an iPhone-like customizable touch screen that replaces your typical “radio dials”
  • Ability to have text and tweets read aloud to you via Ford’s Sync technology
  • Ability to send text or tweets via voice command

Mulally also has a vision of changing Dealer Show Rooms into an experience more akin to an Apple Store.  Rather than having giant lots filled with hundreds of cars/weeds the vision is a clean, open dealership with showcase cars where users can interact via technology and order cars suited to their needs.

What is striking to me about Ford is that many people often ask about the ROI of social media.  With the great work of Mulally, James Farley and Scott Monty at Ford there is something that can’t be measured;  a cultural change.  Progressive thinking from the top down causes this to happen both internally and externally.  The revitalization of Ford is much more than social media and technology, but social media and technology are playing a huge part not only in the bottom line, but also in the perception and culture of Ford; which is often the bottom line of tomorrow.  So, perhaps a more important question is:  What is the ROI on a positive cultural change?

Bookmark and Share

→ 3 CommentsCategories: Social Media
Tagged: , ,

Apple Tablet: The Promise by Sports Illustrated

January 7, 2010 · 4 Comments

By Erik Qualman

This is a great video from Sports Illustrated showcasing the potential promise of the Apple Tablet or any Tablet like device.

As we know at some point (the WSJ on 1/05 reported a ship date of March) we will be privy to the Apple Tablet (originally rumored to be called the Apple Slate). The Tablet should combine the functionality of a PC/eReader/Phone all in one device that has an 10 – 11″ screen. Many things are conjecture at this point including the price point (estimate $1000), but one thing is certain, if this is done correctly it will be a game changer for consumers similar to the iPhone. It will also throw Kerosene on the social media fire as it should make it even easier to be connected anywhere/anytime with full functionality.  In fact some are calling these tablets “media machines.”

This again has been one of the top items at the Consumer Electronics Show (CES) in Vegas.  Many are trying to steal Apple’s potential thunder/unicorn including Lenova, Sony and Microsoft.

For more on CES/Tablet coverage the below are good articles:

PCWorld: Why the Microsoft-HP Tablet is a Big Disappointment by Daniel Inoescu

PCWorld: Meet the Sony Dash: The Latest Tablet to Debut at CES by Ginny Mies

Speaking of CES I thought that it was great to hear Ford sponsoring one of my favorite podcasts – CNET’s Buzz Out Loud with Tom Merritt and Molly Wood – who are covering CES.  Ford has a great presence at CES, which is another sign that James Farley and Scott Monty really “get it.”  They are transforming the Ford brand (how many author auto makers have such a large presence at CES) and I for one can’t wait for the WiFi cars to roll out!

Bookmark and Share

→ 4 CommentsCategories: Apple
Tagged: , , , , ,

Amazon PayPhrase New Twist on Open IDs

January 6, 2010 · Leave a Comment

By Erik Qualman

I finally came across Amazon’s PayPhrase in the “wild” on my Amazon account.   It’s similar in respect to Facebook Connect in that you can start using it across the Web on various sites.  It is   much like some virtual wallets we have seen before.  The funny thing to me was how many popular phrase were already taken like:  “Carpe Diem” “Go For It” “Vida la Vida” “Nothing is Impossible” so, to avoid frustration, try to be original:  “Rainbow Bunny” “Sunny Fargo Beaches.”

It also promises to work as a great virtual wallet for kids/teens – the parent sets the spend limits.

In Amazon’s words:

PayPhrase is an easy-to-remember shortcut to shipping and payment information in your Amazon.com account. Use it for Express Checkout on Amazon.com and across the web. (Learn more)

Why should I use PayPhrase?
Privacy: Shop securely across the web without sharing your credit card
Express Checkout: Speed through checkout without having to sign in
Parental controls: Let teens shop online within limits you set
Where can I use PayPhrase?

Use PayPhrase on Amazon.com and many other web sites, including:

For more information on PayPhrase there is  a good article from Mike Butcher at TechCrunch.

→ Leave a CommentCategories: Social Media · Uncategorized
Tagged: , , , ,